When Previous Experiences Get in the Way of Our Present Reality

We humans are very good at encoding our responses to certain situations—at work, in relationships, and other life contexts. This process is evolutionary, and over time and across populations, increases our chances of survival. It is often helpful to “remember” how something was experienced, so that if it included some level of risk, we know to behave in ways to mitigate or avoid that risk in future situations.

On a personal level, this process can really get in the way.

Because we develop associations between a given stimulus and the outcomes from that stimulus, when we encounter a similar stimulus in the future, we react to it as if it is the same situation from the past. This is why a “bad” experience at work or an emotional hurt in a relationship rears its head in a new work setting or a new relationship. A similar email or facial expression or behavior or tone of voice or even a physical environment can make us feel as if the current situation is the same as the previous situation. Sometimes that is true, but often it is not actually the same in any meaningful way. However, the association we have with the previous experience can be so visceral, particularly if the previous situation was distressing or scary or harmful, that it triggers a “survival” response that can result in reactions on our part that are really provocative, disproportionate, unfair, and confusing to those around us. It’s not that we are consciously trying to create a problem; it’s simply that we are responding to an association that was encoded in a previous experience and we’re trying to protect ourselves.

In my experience working with couples, a whole lot of what is causing conflict in relationships is as much about what happened in previous relationships as it is about what is happening in the moment. In other words, feelings and behaviors are being triggered by associations with experiences from the past that our brains and bodies don’t separate from the present. The feelings and sensations are absolutely real. They’re just misplaced.

Interestingly, these encoded experiences can go all the way back to childhood. For example, an experience with neglect or abandonment by a parent, can manifest decades later in romantic partnerships. We really, really remember things that are emotionally distressing, particularly when some version of survival is at stake.

So what do we do?

The first step is simply to be aware of when present reactions are related to past experiences. This is often not easy or obvious. One of the things I say to couples I work with is that solving a relationship issue may involve solving an individual issue. This can involve partners doing their own individual counseling.

One helpful process is to identify all the “big” feelings we have and when we have them—particularly when our reactions seem out of proportion to what is actually happening in the moment—to track “triggers” and responses. Then, by oneself or with a therapist, think about how far back we can remember experiencing those triggers and responses, in relationships and earlier in life, even in childhood. One reason a therapist can be helpful is that we are trained to support a process like this and to see potential connections and “through lines” that an individual might miss on their own. The process can include examples of when a person was hurt or scared or humiliated or confused or betrayed, etc. When doing trauma work we call this a “trauma map” or “trauma history,” keeping in mind that an experience doesn’t have to meet the criteria of PTSD to affect how we respond in certain situations.

A second step, once we’ve identified past associations that are affecting us in the present, is to note in real time when a particular reaction seems out of proportion or simply reflects what we recognized as a past experience or pattern. In a relationship context, the other person can also be on the lookout for these examples. To be clear, in some cases, particularly when relational trauma is involved, it is highly recommended to address the trauma with a trained therapist.

So, although from an evolutionary perspective, encoding distressing experiences so that we “remember” them later is very helpful at a population level, at an individual level, it can result in us confusing a stimulus in the present as threatening even when it’s not—and then reacting from a place of protecting ourselves with behaviors that aren’t particularly helpful. This dynamic is also a reason to have some grace for ourselves. Evolution is a pretty powerful force.

Leave a Reply